I am waiting for the book in which Stalin's Marxism will appear translated
into Russian history. For it is this which is Russia's strength, what it has of
Russian, not what it has of Communist. Goodness knows what it will be like! The
only thing one can assert is that Russia will require centuries before she can
aspire to command. Because she is still lacking in commandments she has been
obliged to feign adherence to the European principles of Marx. As she has
abundant youth, that fiction is enough for her. Youth does not require reasons
for living, it only needs pretexts. Something very similar is happening with New
York. It is again an error to attribute its actual strength to the commandments
it obeys. In the last resort these are reduced to one- technicism. How strange!
Another European invention, not an American. Technicism is invented by Europe
during the XVIIIth and XIXth Centuries. Again how strange! The very centuries in
which America is coming into existence. And we are told quite seriously that the
essence of America is its practical and technicist conception of life. Instead
of being told that America is, as all colonies are, a rejuvenescence of old
races, in particular of Europe. For different reasons to those in the case of
Russia, the United States also affords an example of that specific historic
reality which we call "a new people." This is looked upon as a mere
phrase, when in reality it is a fact as precise as that of youth in man. America
is strong by reason of its youth, which has put itself at the service of the
modern commandment of technicism, just as it might have put itself at the
service of Buddhism, if that were the order of the day. But while acting thus,
America is only starting its history. It is only now that its trials, its
dissensions, its conflicts, are beginning. It has yet to be many things; amongst
others, some things quite opposed to the technical and the practical. America is
younger than Russia. I have always maintained, though in fear of exaggeration,
that it is a primitive people camouflaged behind the latest inventions.[1] And now Waldo Frank, in his Rediscovery of America, declares this
openly. America has not yet suffered; it is an illusion to think that it can
possess the virtues of command.