This
feeling of another's superiority could only be instilled into him by someone
who, being stronger than he is, should force him to give up some desire, to
restrict himself, to restrain himself. He would then have learned this
fundamental discipline: "Here I end and here begins another more powerful
than I am. In the world, apparently, there are two people: I myself and another
superior to me." The ordinary man of past times was daily taught this
elemental wisdom by the world about him, because it was a world so rudely
organised, that catastrophes were frequent, and there was nothing in it certain,
abundant, stable. But the new masses find themselves in the presence of a
prospect full of possibilities, and furthermore, quite secure, with everything
ready to their hands, independent of any previous efforts on their part, just as
we find the sun in the heavens without our hoisting it up on our shoulders. No
human being thanks another for the air he breathes, for no one has produced the
air for him; it belongs to the sum-total of what "is there," of which
we say "it is natural," because it never fails. And these spoiled
masses are unintelligent enough to believe that the material and social
organisation, placed at their disposition like the air, is of the same origin,
since apparently it never fails them, and is almost as perfect as the natural
scheme of things. My thesis,
therefore, is this: the very perfection with which the XIXth Century gave an
organisation to certain orders of existence has caused the masses benefited
thereby to consider it, not as an organised, but as a natural system. Thus is
explained and defined the absurd state of mind revealed by these masses; they
are only concerned with their own well-being, and at the same time they remain
alien to the cause of that well-being. As they do not see, behind the benefits
of civilisation, marvels of invention and construction which can only be
maintained by great effort and foresight, they imagine that their role is
limited to demanding these benefits peremptorily, as if they were natural
rights. In the disturbances caused by scarcity of food, the mob goes in search
of bread, and the means it employs is generally to wreck the bakeries. This may
serve as a symbol of the attitude adopted, on a greater and more complicated
scale, by the masses of to-day towards the civilisation by which they are
supported.